Before July 1, 2017, India had a complex indirect tax system dominated by Value Added Tax (VAT) at the state level, along with excise, service tax, CST, and multiple entry taxes. GST replaced 17 taxes and 23 cesses with one unified tax. Let’s explore how GST compares with VAT and what truly changed.
Understanding the Old VAT System in India:
Under VAT, states taxed goods at each sale point. However, services fell under a separate service tax. This split caused confusion and tax-on-tax issues. In contrast, GST merged VAT, service tax, excise duty, and other levies into one system. GST vs VAT also differs in tax credit flow. VAT allowed limited input tax credit within states.
GST, however, enables seamless credit across goods and services nationwide. Therefore, businesses now offset taxes more efficiently. For example, a manufacturer earlier paid VAT, excise, and CST. Now, GST covers all through CGST, SGST, and IGST. According to IBEF, GST subsumed over 17 indirect taxes and 13 cesses, simplifying compliance.
Impact on Indian Businesses and MSMEs:
GST vs VAT significantly changed business operations. Earlier, companies faced check posts and varied state rules. After GST, interstate movement became smoother. Moreover, logistics costs dropped due to faster transit. Small businesses initially struggled with digital compliance.
However, GST introduced composition schemes to ease their burden. Therefore, MSMEs gained flexibility despite early challenges. GST also improved formalization. The Economic Times reported that average monthly GST collections crossed ₹1.6 lakh crore in FY24, reflecting a broader tax base. This growth shows increased compliance and transparency.
How GST Simplified Indirect Taxation:
GST replaced VAT and several other indirect taxes on 1 July 2017. It introduced a “One Nation, One Tax” concept. Unlike VAT, GST applies to both goods and services. Moreover, it allows seamless input tax credit across the supply chain. This reduced cascading significantly.
India adopted a dual GST model. It includes CGST, SGST, and IGST. Therefore, both Centre and States share tax revenue transparently. According to IBEF, GST subsumed over 17 central and state taxes. Today, India has over 1.4 crore registered GST taxpayers, showing wider tax base coverage.
Compliance, Transparency, and Technology:
GST vs VAT marks a clear shift toward technology-driven taxation. VAT relied heavily on manual filings and state portals. GST introduced a unified online GSTN platform. Therefore, registrations, returns, and refunds became centralized. E-invoicing and e-way bills further improved tracking. Moreover, this reduced tax evasion and increased accountability.
However, frequent rule changes initially confused taxpayers. In addition, GST compliance frequency increased for some firms. Yet, standardized processes improved long-term clarity.
Benefits, Challenges, and What Changed for Consumers:
For consumers, GST vs VAT brought transparent pricing. Taxes now appear clearly on invoices. Moreover, reduced cascading lowered prices in many categories. However, GST faced early challenges. Frequent rate changes and technical glitches confused small businesses. Over time, reforms simplified return filing and compliance.
From an economic view, GST improved formalization. It encouraged businesses to register and report correctly. Therefore, long-term tax revenue stability improved. In addition, GST supports better policy decisions using real-time data.
Conclusion:
In short, GST vs VAT changed India’s tax system completely. VAT was confusing and added taxes on top of taxes. GST made things simpler and more transparent. Businesses now get easier tax credits and can trade across states smoothly. Consumers see clear prices, and the government collects taxes more efficiently. Explore more GST insights now!
– Ketaki Dandekar (Team Arthology)
Read more about GST vs VAT here – https://cleartax.in/dgst-vat